Below you will find a list of dates and what was known about the elements or the structure of the atom at this time. When designing your first table you can use only the facts available at the time of discovery of your element. That means anything that predates your discovery. When doing your second table you are working in the present so you can use any information available today.
Ancient Civilizations:
Density
Melting Point
Boiling Point
Appearance
Phase (solid, liquid, gas at STP)
Reactivity
Macroscopic crystal structure
1600's:
Atomic mass
1800's:
Composition of compounds formed
1897:
Discovered electron
1900:
Discovered Protons
1911:
Proved the charge on the electron
1912:
Found isotopes
Concept of average atomic mass
1914:
Atomic number
1932:
Discovered Neutron